CAIE
Business
(9609)
2024
May/June Paper 22
Questions & Answers
Q1b(i).
Short Answer
3 marks
Refer to Table 1.1. Calculate the variances in 2023 (x, y and z) and state whether each variance is favourable or adverse.
Model Answer:
x, y and z should be calculated from Table 1.1 and each variance identified as favourable or adverse.
Explanation: The table needed to calculate the exact figures is not included in the provided text.
Q1b(ii).
Short Answer
3 marks
Explain one benefit to PS of using incremental budgeting.
Model Answer:
Incremental budgeting is quick and easy to prepare because it starts with the previous budget and adjusts it for expected changes.
Explanation: This is a standard benefit of incremental budgeting.
Q1c.
Structured
8 marks
Analyse one advantage and one disadvantage to PS of using an assessment centre when selecting a Marketing Manager.
Model Answer:
An assessment centre can give PS a more accurate view of a candidate’s skills because it tests them in realistic tasks, such as teamwork, problem-solving and communication, which are important for a Marketing Manager.
Explanation: Assessment centres assess candidates in practice rather than relying only on interviews or CVs.
Model Answer:
A disadvantage is that assessment centres are expensive and time-consuming to organise, so PS may face higher recruitment costs and delays in filling the vacancy.
Explanation: Assessment centres usually require multiple assessors, activities and facilities.
Q1d.
Essay
12 marks
Evaluate the role of effective packaging for PS.
Model Answer:
Effective packaging can help PS attract customers by improving product appearance, creating brand identity and providing information or protection for the product. It may also influence buying decisions at the point of sale and help differentiate PS’s products from competitors. However, packaging can increase costs, and if the product is not of good quality, attractive packaging alone will not ensure sales. The importance of packaging depends on the target market, the type of product and the extent of competition. Overall, packaging is important, but its role is strongest when combined with a good product and effective marketing.
Explanation: A balanced evaluation considers both marketing benefits and cost/quality limitations.
Q2a(i).
Short Answer
1 mark
Identify one type of training.
Model Answer:
On-the-job training.
Explanation: This is a valid type of training.
Q2a(ii).
Short Answer
3 marks
Explain the term mass market.
Model Answer:
A mass market is a large market made up of many customers with similar needs and wants, so a product is aimed at a wide range of buyers.
Explanation: This matches the standard business definition of mass market.
Q2b(i).
Short Answer
3 marks
Refer to Table 2.1. Calculate the contribution per unit for the recent batch of shoes.
Model Answer:
Contribution per unit = total contribution ÷ output. Using the data, total contribution = $25,000 - $18,750 = $6,250. Output = 400 + 100 = 500 units. Contribution per unit = $6,250 ÷ 500 = $12.50 per unit.
Explanation: Contribution is total revenue minus total variable costs, then divided by output.
Q2b(ii).
Short Answer
3 marks
Explain one limitation for CS of using break-even analysis.
Model Answer:
Break-even analysis assumes costs and revenue are linear and that all output is sold, which may not be realistic for CS because demand for shoes can change and prices may vary.
Explanation: A key limitation is that break-even analysis is based on simplifying assumptions.
Q2c.
Structured
8 marks
Analyse two disadvantages to CS of adopting a JIT approach to inventory management.
Model Answer:
One disadvantage is that CS could face production delays if the supplier fails to deliver leather on time, because JIT keeps very low inventory levels and there may be no buffer stock.
Explanation: JIT increases dependence on reliable deliveries.
Model Answer:
Another disadvantage is that CS may lose the ability to meet sudden increases in demand, since it would not hold much finished stock in the shop or much raw material in storage.
Explanation: Low inventory levels can reduce flexibility and responsiveness.
Q2d.
Essay
12 marks
Evaluate the importance to CS of being a small business.
Model Answer:
Being a small business can be important to CS because it may allow close contact with customers, flexibility in design, lower bureaucracy and the ability to specialise in niche markets. This could suit a business making unique shoes and offering repairs. However, being small can also limit access to finance, reduce economies of scale and make it harder to compete with low-priced mass producers. For CS, the importance of being small depends on whether it wants to remain niche and personalised or expand to compete more widely. Overall, being small is likely to be an advantage for CS if it focuses on custom-made shoes and customer service, but it may also restrict growth and profitability.
Explanation: A strong evaluation weighs the benefits of flexibility and niche focus against scale and competitive disadvantages.